Monday, November 16, 2026

The perils of Democratic timidity

This performance of Woody Guthrie’s “This Land Is Your Land” at Obama’s inauguration ceremony in 2009 is a reminder of the hopeful feeling among many voters that the aggressively partisan Bush II era was finally over. (1)


After the bitter recriminations of the Bush-Cheney years driven by the aggressively partisan posture embodied by Dick Cheney, Obama’s signature message of turning back the page to something less toxic sounded very appealing. He said in his 2008 victory speech after he won:
If there is anyone out there who still doubts that America is a place where all things are possible; who still wonders if the dream of our founders is alive in our time; who still questions the power of our democracy, tonight is your answer. ...

If there is anyone out there who still doubts that America is a place where all things are possible; who still wonders if the dream of our founders is alive in our time; who still questions the power of our democracy, tonight is your answer. … It's the answer spoken by young and old, rich and poor, Democrat and Republican, black, white, Latino, Asian, Native American, gay, straight, disabled and not disabled - Americans who sent a message to the world that we have never been a collection of red states and blue states; we are, and always will be, the United States of America. (2)
The Republicans’ message was and remains today more so than ever: We want to crush the Democrats and do away with as much of democracy and the rule of law as we can achieve. To be fair to the Republican reactionaries of 2008, the Trump cult raised that approach to a new level of intensity – and of actual violence in the form of ICE thugs literally murdering people in the streets of American cities.

Obama’s Presidency was certainly not equivalent to Donald’s Trump two turns at the wheel. The arms-control agreement with Iran (JCPOA) alone is enough of an example to illustrate that – especially now that we see the current Iran War which a stable arms agreement like JCPOA was meant to avoid in a way that enhanced the security of everyone in the Middle East.

But it’s also worth remembering that when this celebration of solidarity and tolerance on Obama’s Inauguration Day was occurring, Obama was already pursuing an impossible dream of bipartisan harmony with a seriously radicalized Republican Party. And Dick Cheney’s Republican Party was not interested in feel-good bipartisan cooperation – as we saw through all eight years of Obama’s Presidency. And it very clearly did not succeed. The Republicans radicalized themselves from the very ugly and divisive Dick Cheney version of the party to the Donald Trump/Stephen Miller version. A radicalization process that continues until this day – with no end in sight on the Republican side.

A nearly-forgotten symbolic moment early in Obama’s Presidency was Obama’s stunt of encouraging Democrats and Republicans to pick buddies from the “other side of the aisle” (one of the most tiresome clichés of legacy-media reporters’) to sit next to them at Obama’s first State of the Union address. As PBS reported at the time:
Amid new calls for political civility after the Tucson shooting, Sen. Mark Udall, D-Colo., and Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, have led a campaign for a bipartisan seating plan at Tuesday's State of the Union -- reversing a tradition that usually sees members sit on opposite sides of the aisle during the president's address. The idea was first presented by the centrist Democratic group Third Way.

The plan has led to a few rare pairings. We've asked the NewsHour's political team to help us recap a few of those "odd couples" and give them a rating of high -- for very unusual political partners -- to low for those lawmakers who regularly work or collaborate together. For a full list of known seating partners, check The Hill, which has compiled a roster. (3)
Meanwhile, the Republicans were organizing the Tea Party protests and rejoicing at Obama’s Look Forward Not Backward slogan he used to justify his Justice Department – whose Attorney General came from a prominent Wall Street securities law firm – not conducting any serious investigations at all of the crimes committed by senior Bush officials in fabricating evidence to justify the disastrous Iraq War and the very ugly and criminal torture program that was one Dick Cheney’s other pet projects.

Then there was Obama’s “Very Serious People” strategy, as Paul Krugman famously called the advocates of Bipartisan surrender to the Republicans at the time. The blogger and columnist Heather “Digby” Parton was raising the alarm even before Obama’s Inauguration that the notion of a bipartisan “Grand Bargain” with the Republicans was a disaster on both policy and partisan grounds. The idea was the Democrats would agree to cutting Social Security by raising the full Social Security Retirement Age from 65 to 67 - which Congress passed during Reagan’s first term – to 69. A repeat of Regan’s cut to Social Security benefits, which were done at a time where many more workers also had pensions plans from their employers than they did in 2008 when Obama started talking up the idea.

What would the Republicans give up for that deal? They would agree to higher tax rates on top earners – which would surely have included lots of loopholes and which the Republicans would have reduced anyway the first moment they got the chance. This was the idea behind the once-infamous but now largely forgotten Simpson-Bowles Commission, whose job it was to justify that Grand Bargain. Ironically, when the Commission itself wound up not recommending the Grand Bargain, in the form Obama had wanted, he continue to propose it anyway. An attempt which failed, fortunately for the country and the Democratic Party.

But Obama invested much of his political capital in his first two years by pursuing a regressive “bipartisan” vision on such issues. And, of course, the midterm elections of 2010 were a disaster for the Democrats. But Obama stuck with the Grand Bargain hope well into his second term. As Digby herself wrote in 2013: “The ‘bargain’ was about a restructuring of government in which Americans would have to “sacrifice” because “the federal budget is unsustainable.” But once that gets done we would get to have some neat new (cheaper) modern stuff because everyone will know the government is living within its means.” (4)

David Neiwert warned in early 2009 about just how little the Cheney-Bush Republicans cared about “bipartisan” harmony:
We've known all along that Obama is a reach-out-to-your-enemy kind of guy; it's a big part of what made him so electable.

But the experience of the past eight years [the Cheney-Bush years] has made clear that the Republican idea of bipartisanship involves hot pokers and nether regions. When you reach out to them, usually all you have left to show for it is a hand gnawed down to the bone. [emphasis added] (5)
And the Trump takeover of the party put that tendency on steroids. Joe Biden famously and hopefully said about the Republicans after he was elected, “The fever will break.” But the “fever” has only gotten worse.

David Cay Johnston’s recent description of the beneficial effects of expanding federal health insurance is a strong reminder of how effective it can be for Democrats to fight for policies that are both effective and popular, even if they lose the fight in the short run. (6)


Combining the influence of super-rich donors with the hopeless fantasy of convincing Trump-cult adherents to embrace “bipartisanship” - the so-called moderate strategy of avoiding losing fights over popular issues that favor the Democrats - will only show the voters who gave the Democrats an historic win in 2026 that (1) the Democrats are unwilling to fight for their own side, i.e., their own voters; and, (2) not very serious about what they did advocate in the 2026 elections. The conventional Pod Pundits can lecture the voters for not understanding that very practical and beneficial programs like Medicare for All are “just not realistic.”

At a time when building out the Democratic Party organization in all states is a critical priority, sticking to a sternly-worded-letter strategy of opposition to Trump is not likely to be the most effective strategy for the Democrats. (7)

This post originally appeared on the ProDA-Progressive Caucus of Democrats Abroad Substack.

Notes:

(1) Pete Seeger & Bruce Springsteen - This Land is Your Land - Obama Inauguration. Enrico V L YouTube channel 01/28/2014. <https://youtu.be/wnvCPQqQWds?si=n_Arr0AN7mx47_k5> (Accessed: 2026-13-11).

(2) Transcript Of Barack Obama's Victory Speech. NPR 11/05/2008. <https://www.npr.org/2008/11/05/96624326/transcript-of-barack-obamas-victory-speech> (Accessed: 2026-13-11).

(3) Bipartisan Seating at State of the Union Pairs Odd Couples, Friendly Foes. PBS News 01/25/2011. <https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/bipartisan-seating-at-state-of-the-union-pairs-odd-couples-friendly-foes> (Accessed: 2026-13-11).

(4) Parton, Heather “Digby” (2013): The Grand Bargain was not conceived as a budget negotiation. Hullabaloo 10/30/2013. <https://digbysblog.net/2013/10/30/the-grand-bargain-was-not-conceived-as/> (Accessed: 2026-13-11).

(5) Neiwert, David (2009): Will Obama Still Have A Hand After Reaching Out To Republicans? Crooks & Liars 01/03/2009. <https://crooksandliars.com/david-neiwert/will-obama-still-have-hand-after-rea> (Accessed: 2026-13-11).

(6) Trump Starting to Crack From the Pressure. The Mark Thompson Show YouTube channel 11/11/2026. <https://youtu.be/5g-oNjc-smc?si=0htANsCn0AuMivBQ> (Accessed: 2026-13-11).

(7) Macini, Ryan (2025): ‘Pathetic’: Critics cringe at leading Dem’s ‘very strong letter’ to Trump. Yahoo!News 04/24/2025. <https://www.yahoo.com/news/pathetic-critics-cringe-leading-dem-191116497.html> (Accessed: 2026-13-11).

No comments:

Post a Comment